My court conviction – for bid to free trapped birds

First published in Echo News

A UNIVERSITY academic and wildlife specialist was convicted of criminal damage after breaking the window of a derelict shop in a bid to free trapped pigeons.

Doctor Michael Costello, who has a PhD and a first class honours degree in zoology, was handed a six-month conditional discharge at Basildon Crown Court Costello is a volunteer for an organisation that specialises in freeing trapped animals.

He received a call on January 29 from a woman who said pigeons had been trapped inside an abandoned shop in Southend High Street for about five days.

Costello, 69, of Lewisham, travelled to the shop, which is owned by Levar Commerical Finance Limited.

He took out tools to break a back window, but was spotted by a woman who phoned police.

He was arrested before he could free the birds.

The court heard that a day later the building’s owners contacted the RSPCA to free the pigeons Costello told the court that at the time of the incident he believed he had a duty to free the birds under section four of the Animal Welfare Act.

He pleaded guilty to criminal damage.

But Costello, who has published a book called the World Of Birds, said he felt he should never have been prosecuted for the incident.

He said: “I have been rescuing animals for about 40 years.

“I was told the animals had been there for about five days.

“Usually, birds will die about this time if they do not have access to food and water. The way I see it, it is like seeing a dog at the point of death, trapped in a hot car on a summer’s day, and breaking the window to save its life.

“I don’t think I should have been prosecuted.”

Costello carries a large trolley with him that contains a bird rescue kit, including a cardboard pet carrier and a net, in case he is called to an emergency.

He added: “I consider it a matter of duty for us to help distressed animals.

“I don’t necessarily consider this my life’s work, but I can’t just pass by when I see an animal suffering.”

Costello stressed he was not asked to attend the incident by his employer. He said his details had been passed to the Southend woman by a third party.

Comments (6)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

7:35am Thu 12 Jun 14

Robin Reliant says...

yes i see that,really was not worth the grief for a few pigeons which are filthy pests anyway, how about prosecuting the buildings owners for leaving it in a poor eyesore state which brings the High street down, they should use the boards like in the royals/lakeside when theres an empty shop.
yes i see that,really was not worth the grief for a few pigeons which are filthy pests anyway, how about prosecuting the buildings owners for leaving it in a poor eyesore state which brings the High street down, they should use the boards like in the royals/lakeside when theres an empty shop. Robin Reliant
  • Score: -2

7:48am Thu 12 Jun 14

Richy don't shine shoes no more says...

Welcome to Southend. The home of zero tolerance only when it suits
Welcome to Southend. The home of zero tolerance only when it suits Richy don't shine shoes no more
  • Score: 9

8:28am Thu 12 Jun 14

sesibollox says...

Those flying rats should have been shot, who in their right mind would break a window with the lame excuse of trying to save a pigeon ?
Those flying rats should have been shot, who in their right mind would break a window with the lame excuse of trying to save a pigeon ? sesibollox
  • Score: -8

12:53pm Thu 12 Jun 14

SLord90 says...

sesibollox wrote:
Those flying rats should have been shot, who in their right mind would break a window with the lame excuse of trying to save a pigeon ?
They're animals. All animals have rights. Respect that.
[quote][p][bold]sesibollox[/bold] wrote: Those flying rats should have been shot, who in their right mind would break a window with the lame excuse of trying to save a pigeon ?[/p][/quote]They're animals. All animals have rights. Respect that. SLord90
  • Score: 5

12:54pm Thu 12 Jun 14

SLord90 says...

Poor bloke, only trying to do good! Hope this doesn't stop him from still rescuing birds!
Poor bloke, only trying to do good! Hope this doesn't stop him from still rescuing birds! SLord90
  • Score: 12

3:23pm Thu 12 Jun 14

emcee says...

Dying dogs trapped in a car and pests trapped in a building are two completely different things. There is no evidence these pigeons were even distressed, only the say so of some do-gooder.
If Mr Costello decides to go all vigilante then he should be prepared to accept the consequences. If he was that concerned he could quite easily have pestered the owners of the shop and let them deal with it. It was not his (Mr Costello's) responsibility for the welfare of these birds. Does he feel he has the right to break and enter any property on the "suspicion" of animals in distress?
Dying dogs trapped in a car and pests trapped in a building are two completely different things. There is no evidence these pigeons were even distressed, only the say so of some do-gooder. If Mr Costello decides to go all vigilante then he should be prepared to accept the consequences. If he was that concerned he could quite easily have pestered the owners of the shop and let them deal with it. It was not his (Mr Costello's) responsibility for the welfare of these birds. Does he feel he has the right to break and enter any property on the "suspicion" of animals in distress? emcee
  • Score: 2

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree