Hospital blunders led to girl’s death

Southend Standard: Hospital blunders led to girl’s death Hospital blunders led to girl’s death

A TEN-YEAR-OLD girl died after a catalogue of blunders at Basildon Hospital, an inquest found.

Shortages of senior medics, delays, and out-of-date medicines meant the trust was unable to stop epileptic Arina Durbazeva fitting before she suffered a heart attack, Chelmsford Coroners’ Court heard.

Arina, from Maunder Close, Grays, was born at the hospital and had been a regular patient after being diagnosed with epilepsy, aged one.

She was admitted to the paediatric unit on October 12, last year, for checks after suffering an epileptic seizure at school, which stopped after being treated with an anti-seizure drug.

However, she had a second seizure at the hospital soon after arriving at 4.20pm, but a series of subsequent errors meant it could not be contained.

She suffered the heart attack at 6.05pm and stopped breathing for 14 minutes before being transferred to St Mary’s Hospital, London, where she died two days later.

Giving a narrative verdict Coroner Caroline Beasley- Murray said: “There were serious failings in the care provided during her treatment at Basildon Hospital.”

The failings were:

  •  No set treatment plans for regular patients ! An inexperienced medic struggled to mix a dose of the same drug used to stop the previous seizure and the delay meant it did failed to work.
  • Junior doctors chose not to administer three other types of drugs which should be tried if the first treatment failed, as the only stocks on the ward were out of date. It was later established they should have been tried anyway.
  • Pharmaceutical staff should have replenished and destroyed out-of-date drugs, but failed to do so ! Despite warning signs under a child patient risk system, there were repeated delays in alerting an on-call consultant to her deteriorating condition ! A lack of senior nursing staff, no senior doctors were ever at the ward after 5pm and the oncall locum consultant Dr Mohamed Ramadan chose to stay at home when contacted.
  • Two anaestistists on site could not get to her bedside until after the heart attack.

A post mortem found she died from multiple organ failure contributed by epilepsy, an associated brain problem and obesity.

The court heard the death also led to two independent reviews and an action plan to prevent a repeat being implemented.

It included regular drug date checks, consultants on site until 9pm, tailor-made care plans for those with complex illnesses, and staff made to contact senior staff more quickly.

Ms Beasley-Murray added: “I am pleased to see there have been some improvements in places, but they must be ongoing and must be implemented.

“There is no point having an action plan unless it is implemented fully so little girls like this much-loved girl are not at risk.”

ARINA’S father still wants answers from Basildon Hospital over his daughter’s death.

Arkadiys Durbazeva, 40, cross examined Dr Rotimi Jaiyesimi who investigated the failings.

He said: “There is a void in our understanding of how a situation as dire as this was allowed to exist in the hospital.”

He did not accept some of the doctor’s claims and timescales given in evidence.

The hospital said the seizure lasted 45 minutes, but Mr Durbazev said records showed it was an hour and 45 minutes.

Despite being in charge of the investigation, Dr Jaiyesimi said he could not comment on why other measures recommended in the treatment plan for epileptics were not carried out.

There was also confusion over the timing of when the anaesthetists were first contacted, two other calls made by junior doctors, and who was in charge during her treatment, which the medic was unable to address.

Mr Durbazeva added: “There are definite discrepancies between our understanding and the definitions of certain events given this afternoon and the timescales. Unless we get satisfactory answers, we reserve the right to seek further responses.”

The court heard evidence of failings in her care that typified the myriad of problems identified by the national review into failing trusts across the country, which singled out several hospitals, including Basildon, with the highest preventable death rates, having severe staff shortages and lack of senior doctors available at the busiest times.

DOCTOR Rotimi Jaiyesimi, Basildon Hospital’s director of patient safety, carried out an internal investigation into the death.

He accepted there was a delay in mixing the initial drugs.

He said: “Perhaps the person mixing it did not know what to do. If it had been a senior person perhaps it would have been given earlier.

“In years gone by nursing staff had responsibility for out-ofdate drugs, but there were documents saying it was the responsibility of pharmacy, but they did not do it.

“There was a delay in escalating treatment when the first treatment was not effective.

“I would expect junior doctors to have contacted consultants.”

On call consultant Dr Ramadan no longer works for the trust and is based in Libya, so did not give evidence.

Dr Jaiyesimi added: “The consultant should have probed further about the deterioration. It is difficult for me to comment on his decision to stay at home.”

Asked about repeated delays in getting consultants involved, he added: “When you are in a bubble, you lose track of time.

“We have spoken about it across the trust and if a junior doctor calls. you must ask relevant questions.“ BASILDON Hospital’s chief executive Clare Panniker gave a personal apology to the family after the inquest.

She said: “I want to say how sorry I am that we failed to provide the best care to Arina.

“I also want to assure her family that she will not be forgotten and will remain at the forefront of our minds as we seek to improve the care we provide to all our patients.

“We have worked tirelessly to learn lessons from her death and, as a result, the care we provide to children has been transformed.”

She said the hospital now employed higher numbers of specialist paediatric nurses and three additional consultants. She added: “We have changed the way some children access paediatric services out of hours to ensure they are safe at all times.

“A review of the way we manage medicines has also been undertaken to ensure they are available and in stock at all times.”

Comments (12)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

9:29am Tue 10 Dec 13

CHRISTMAS CAROL says...

Bit too late for sorry. Basildon hospital again!!!!!!
Bit too late for sorry. Basildon hospital again!!!!!! CHRISTMAS CAROL

9:34am Tue 10 Dec 13

Vange Resident says...

I feel terrible for the family and my thought and condolence go out to all those suffering with this loss.
Once again Basildon Hospital has let the community down, mixed with some appalling failures there is lots of good work done but this is inexcusable, I worked in this hospital for 7 years and saw the work the paediatric dept. The doctors and senior staff as far too busy doing other things rather than looking out for the patients, most are working in private clinics and not on site, there direct managers turn a blind eye as do the senior managers as well as the trust board of directors, I have said it many times but ALL the management needs to be sacked for gross failure and they need to be replaced, this includes the head of nursing, director of finance and the whole of the board of directors! The OLD chief exec has a lot to answer for!
I feel terrible for the family and my thought and condolence go out to all those suffering with this loss. Once again Basildon Hospital has let the community down, mixed with some appalling failures there is lots of good work done but this is inexcusable, I worked in this hospital for 7 years and saw the work the paediatric dept. The doctors and senior staff as far too busy doing other things rather than looking out for the patients, most are working in private clinics and not on site, there direct managers turn a blind eye as do the senior managers as well as the trust board of directors, I have said it many times but ALL the management needs to be sacked for gross failure and they need to be replaced, this includes the head of nursing, director of finance and the whole of the board of directors! The OLD chief exec has a lot to answer for! Vange Resident

10:29am Tue 10 Dec 13

Idontknowy says...

Very sad.
Very sad. Idontknowy

10:32am Tue 10 Dec 13

Avondale says...

How many more times will this happen? Time for some heads to roll.
How many more times will this happen? Time for some heads to roll. Avondale

11:25am Tue 10 Dec 13

Audioman says...

Damm Basildon Hospital again
Should be closed down and all the staff
sacked and not work again in ANY hospital
any were in the world
Damm Basildon Hospital again Should be closed down and all the staff sacked and not work again in ANY hospital any were in the world Audioman

12:35pm Tue 10 Dec 13

emcee says...

There are many sackable offences in play here (mainly from managment) but are we to see any sackings? I doubt it.
It really is a travesty that so many people in a position of being trusted with peoples lives (and many who are paid very well to do so), betray that trust but are allowed to remain in that position.
Heads really need to start rolling, especially higher up the chain, to show other staff that gross neglegence on this scale is not to be tolerated. Unless this happens, people lives will continually be treated as a triviality.
There are many sackable offences in play here (mainly from managment) but are we to see any sackings? I doubt it. It really is a travesty that so many people in a position of being trusted with peoples lives (and many who are paid very well to do so), betray that trust but are allowed to remain in that position. Heads really need to start rolling, especially higher up the chain, to show other staff that gross neglegence on this scale is not to be tolerated. Unless this happens, people lives will continually be treated as a triviality. emcee

12:52pm Tue 10 Dec 13

Vange Resident says...

emcee wrote:
There are many sackable offences in play here (mainly from managment) but are we to see any sackings? I doubt it. It really is a travesty that so many people in a position of being trusted with peoples lives (and many who are paid very well to do so), betray that trust but are allowed to remain in that position. Heads really need to start rolling, especially higher up the chain, to show other staff that gross neglegence on this scale is not to be tolerated. Unless this happens, people lives will continually be treated as a triviality.
I Agree, there appears to be a protective “Cloak” around all those that work at this Hospital! We need to see this hospital shut down and remove ALL the management because clearly the management has led to far too many deaths and failings!
[quote][p][bold]emcee[/bold] wrote: There are many sackable offences in play here (mainly from managment) but are we to see any sackings? I doubt it. It really is a travesty that so many people in a position of being trusted with peoples lives (and many who are paid very well to do so), betray that trust but are allowed to remain in that position. Heads really need to start rolling, especially higher up the chain, to show other staff that gross neglegence on this scale is not to be tolerated. Unless this happens, people lives will continually be treated as a triviality.[/p][/quote]I Agree, there appears to be a protective “Cloak” around all those that work at this Hospital! We need to see this hospital shut down and remove ALL the management because clearly the management has led to far too many deaths and failings! Vange Resident

1:44pm Tue 10 Dec 13

Kim Gandy says...

How many of these staff are fluent in English?
How many of these staff are fluent in English? Kim Gandy

3:39pm Tue 10 Dec 13

Mikkel1 says...

Rest assured folks, Basildon Hospital is NOT alone these days.

The loss of the youngsters life is nothing short of DISGUSTING, and far too many Managers in EVERY hospital, getting extortionate salaries and allowing these things to happen, but NEVER get fired. WHY?

I took photo's of a Dirty ward in one hospital 3 years ago, and it was Months before it was cleaned. NOT Basildon though.
Rest assured folks, Basildon Hospital is NOT alone these days. The loss of the youngsters life is nothing short of DISGUSTING, and far too many Managers in EVERY hospital, getting extortionate salaries and allowing these things to happen, but NEVER get fired. WHY? I took photo's of a Dirty ward in one hospital 3 years ago, and it was Months before it was cleaned. NOT Basildon though. Mikkel1

4:29pm Tue 10 Dec 13

TherealIndiana says...

And the madness continues, but lessons have been learned and procedures put in place, but it still continues........
And the madness continues, but lessons have been learned and procedures put in place, but it still continues........ TherealIndiana

8:59am Wed 11 Dec 13

Discouraged says...

Shame on the people concerned and shame on us for not getting together and forcing our hospitals to improve.
Shame on the people concerned and shame on us for not getting together and forcing our hospitals to improve. Discouraged

1:07pm Thu 12 Dec 13

EthanEdwards says...

NHS the envy of the world. Danny Boyle's dancing doctors at the Olympics...all looks a bit naff now doesn't it. I thought it was a load of old 'row-locks' at the time.
NHS the envy of the world. Danny Boyle's dancing doctors at the Olympics...all looks a bit naff now doesn't it. I thought it was a load of old 'row-locks' at the time. EthanEdwards

Comments are closed on this article.

click2find

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree